Patent decision

BL number
O/002/13
Concerning rights in
GB2473845
Hearing Officer
Mr A C Howard
Decision date
4 January 2013
Person(s) or Company(s) involved
MotoCaddy Limited v Andrew Barry Bridle
Provisions discussed
Patents Act 1977 section 74B
Keywords
Opinions and Reviews
Related Decisions
O/003/13

Summary

The decision relates to a request for review of opinion 02/12. The patent relates to an electrically powered golf trolley having a USB socket which can be used to power an electrical component (e.g. a portable music player), and means to support such a component. The opinion related to the question of whether another golf trolley infringed the patent and found that there was no infringement. The proprietor requested a review on the grounds that the examiner had wrongly construed the claim. The Hearing Officer found that the examiner had not made an error of principle or reached a conclusion that was clearly wrong, and therefore refused to set aside the opinion.

Full decision O/002/13 PDF document132Kb